Exercise Before and After Surgery: What Studies Show
-
Daniel -
October 2, 2026 at 1:58 PM -
174 Views -
0 Replies
For anyone facing major surgery, one thing matters most: getting through the procedure and subsequent recovery as well as possible. Exercise may play a role. However, two analyses and studies published on September 29, 2026, also show how important it is to take a close look at the results. Not every improvement is equally pronounced, and not every open question can be answered yet.
Training Before Surgery: Improvements, but Only Marginally in the Walking Test
An analysis of 42 studies involving a total of 4,825 adults examined exercise programs before colorectal, lung, heart, vascular, and other major surgeries. In 30 studies, the exercise was supervised; in twelve studies, participants trained independently.
Both approaches were associated with improvements in the six-minute walk test. In the analyses, however, the average improvement was less than one meter. At first, that sounds underwhelming. Anyone preparing for surgery might quickly ask after seeing such a result: Is the effort worth it at all?
A different picture emerged for complications after surgery. In studies involving supervised aerobic exercise, postoperative complications were associated with approximately 40 percent lower odds. With high-intensity exercise, the odds of such complications were approximately halved.
Even so, caution is important when interpreting the results. None of the studies directly compared supervised with unsupervised exercise. Therefore, the findings cannot establish a cause-and-effect conclusion about the role of supervision. In other words, the analysis shows associations but does not prove that supervision itself was responsible for the differences.
This leaves a nuanced picture. In the studies examined, exercise before major surgery was associated with certain improvements. However, the measurable difference in the six-minute walk test was small. At the same time, fewer postoperative complications were observed with certain forms of exercise. Both aspects belong in the overall interpretation of the results.
After ACL Reconstruction, Supervision Initially Offers Greater Benefits
The type of exercise therapy can also make a difference after surgery. A randomized clinical trial examined 184 adults between 18 and 40 years of age. All of them continued to experience knee symptoms nine to 36 months after ACL reconstruction.
Two approaches were compared: Some participants took part in a supervised exercise and education program. The other group received a one-time educational session and then performed self-directed exercises.
After four months, the supervised group reported greater improvements in symptoms and quality of life. Their thigh muscles were also stronger. Participants in this group also more frequently described a subjective feeling of recovery. This can be decisive, especially in everyday life: It is not only a question of whether a knee functions better on paper, but also whether the affected person actually feels more recovered.
After twelve months, the gap between the groups had narrowed. The initial advantage of supervised exercise therapy had therefore become smaller. There were no differences in cartilage thickness.
Supervision Is Not a Free Pass for Grand Promises
Above all, the two investigations make one thing clear: Exercise and recovery cannot be reduced to a simple formula for success. Before major surgery, both supervised and independent training were associated with improvements in the six-minute walk test, though on average only to a limited extent. After ACL reconstruction, a supervised program initially showed more pronounced benefits in symptoms, quality of life, muscle strength, and the personal perception of recovery.
At the same time, the difference shrank over the course of follow-up, and no difference was found in cartilage thickness. So anyone hearing quick and comprehensive promises should take a closer look. What matters is which outcomes were actually studied—and which questions remain unanswered.